Why 2026 should terrify Republicans after Tennessee special election

Opinion

Why 2026 should terrify Republicans after Tennessee special election

Matt Van Epps won Tennessee's special election by only 9 points despite Trump's involvement in the race in a state he carried by over 20 points in 2024

Kevin Walling Fox News

Published

December 4, 2025 4:19pm EST

Video

Republican Rep.-elect Matt Van Epps of Tennessee is sworn into Congress 2 days after winning a special election

Rep.-elect Matt Van Epps of Tennessee, who won a hotly contested special congressional election is sworn in as the 220th Republican member of the House of Representatives.

NEW

You can now listen to Fox News articles!

As the old saying goes, "close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades," and the GOP is certainly breathing a sigh of relief coming out of Tuesday night’s special election for Tennessee’s 7th Congressional District. Republican Matt Van Epps defeated Democrat Aftyn Behn by nine points in a race that received a great deal of national attention in recent weeks.

Why 2026 should terrify Republicans after Tennessee election

THE TENNESSEE 'WALTZ': REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS DANCE AROUND SPECIAL ELECTION RESULTS MEANING

That relief, however, will be short lived upon further analysis because President Trump carried TN-7 by more than 20 points just a year ago and the district hasn’t elected a Democrat to Congress in more than four decades. Despite millions in outside GOP spending, direct on-the-ground involvement from Speaker Johnson and President Trump himself, last night’s results represent a 13-point shift towards the Democrats compared to 2024.

Republican Rep. Matt Van Epps of Tennessee, left, shakes hands with Speaker Mike Johnson after being sworn in to the U.S. House, on Capitol Hill in Washington D.C. on Dec. 4, 2025 (AP)

For Republicans who spent the last month downplaying Democratic overperformance statewide in Virginia and New Jersey and in key elections in traditionally friendlier territories in Georgia, Texas and Mississippi, last night should be a wake-up call for Team Red.

Here are five key takeaways from the results and what they mean for next year’s battle for Congress come November.

TRUMP-BACKED VAN EPPS SWORN IN AS GOP HITS 220 SEATS — BUT INCOMING GREENE EXIT THREATENS RAZOR-THIN MAJORITY

Democrats lost the race, but they continue to win the argument

Earlier this week appearing on "Fox & Friends," Tennessee Republican Rep. Tim Burchett declared that this "special election shouldn’t be this close, but it is." Burchett is right, this is a ruby red Republican district that last sent a Democrat to Congress in the Reagan Administration. Republicans poured more than $3 million into this race and deployed every tried-and-true attack line from calling Behn "an anti-Tennessee radical progressive" to "defund the police" – and Van Epps barely scraped by.

This is a 'calamity waiting to happen': Rep Burchett

Video

Democrats have been consistently performing better in key off-year elections throughout 2025. With Behn’s 13-point improvement over 2024 results, Team Blue has overperformed in 220 out of 248 races — nearly 90% — compared with just one year ago.

SURVEY SAYS: ISSUE THAT HELPED TRUMP AND REPUBLICANS IN 2024 HURT THEM NOW

The GOP retirement crisis just got a lot worse

It’s important to remember why last night’s special election was being held in the first place. Rep. Mark Green, who had served in this seat since 2019 and chaired the House Homeland Security Committee abruptly announced last June that he was leaving Congress to pursue a private sector job almost certainly with better pay, less travel and easier hours.

TRUMP-BACKED REPUBLICAN TOUTS 'GREAT TURNOUT FOR US' IN MUST-WIN SPECIAL ELECTION FOR GOP

Already this year, 44 lawmakers – more than 1 in 10 – have announced they are not seeking election or, in Green’s case, have already retired, with the majority of them being members of the House GOP caucus. Given Tuesday night’s results and the uncertainty around mid-cycle redistricting, that retirement trend is likely to increase, giving Democrats the advantage of competing in more open seat races.

House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., ceremonially swears in Representative Matt Van Epps, R-Tenn., with his wife Meg Wrather and their daughter Amelia Van Epps, on his daughter’s pink Bible at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C., on December 4, 2025 (Jonathan Ernst/REUTERS)

It's the "affordability" argument, stupid

In 2024, President Trump won the economic argument over Vice President Harris with many voters believing he would tackle inflation on Day One. The electorate had grown tired of "Bidenomics" and rosier pictures of an economy where real Americans were struggling with rising costs, and affordable healthcare and housing.

We are nearly a year into the Trump Administration and the economic paradigm has shifted with the president’s standing on economic issues underwater. In our own Fox News polling from last month, 76% of voters rated the economy as "not so good" or "poor" with just 38% approving of the president’s handling of the economy.

TOP 5 GAME-CHANGERS FROM THE 2025 CAMPAIGN TRAIL

In Tennessee, Behn talked constantly about affordability, inflation and tariffs, taking a play out of the successful messaging playbook employed by the Spanberger and Sherrill campaigns focused on kitchen-table economics. Voters want tangible solutions to real-world economic hardships, and Democrats have learned how to meet the moment while President Trump double downed in Tuesday’s Cabinet meeting that "the word ‘affordability’ is a Democrat scam."

Aftyn Behn delivers a concession speech during an election-night watch party at Marathon Music Works on Dec. 2, 2025 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Jon Cherry/Getty Images)

The 2026 House battlefield just expanded for Democrats – dramatically

Tuesday night’s results build on the narrative that Democrats are overperforming in races – not by single digits, but by double-digits, even in Trump +20 territory. While some pundits will dismiss the results because of the nature of special elections, it’s worth noting that voter turnout was nearly identical to the last midterm election for this district in 2022.

DEMOCRATIC STRATEGIST SAYS TENNESSEE NOMINEE WAS ‘FRINGE OF A FRINGE,’ DOOMED PARTY'S CHANCES

Just as 2018 expanded the map thanks to normal midterm trends and anti-MAGA energy, 2026 may be shaping up to do the same. There are approximately 50 GOP House members currently serving in districts that the president won by 14 points or less – roughly comparable to Tuesday’s vote total.

Senate Majority Leader John Thune previews midterms with Ruthless

Video

For years, Democrats largely surrendered rural and deeply red areas, focusing nearly-exclusively on urban and suburban districts. But 2025 has indicated a different strategy: organize and compete everywhere as Democrats are "all gas and no brakes heading into next year," according to DNC Chairman Ken Martin.

The midterms are shaping up to be a referendum and the GOP isn’t ready

The GOP’s electoral problems are compounding. The president’s standing, generic congressional polling and shrinking margins in deeply red turf all should be a wakeup call to Republican members and strategists.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

Recent infighting among leadership, as evidenced by this week’s spat between Speaker Johnson and Rep. Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., a member of his own leadership team, further drags down GOP prospects. Without a clear message on the economy, voters will continue to see dysfunction from a Washington completely controlled by Republicans and blame the majority party.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Democrats don’t need to win places like TN-7 in 2026 to take back the majority. They just need to get close. On Tuesday, they did far more than that.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM KEVIN WALLING

Kevin Walling is a Democratic campaign strategist, former Biden 2020 campaign surrogate, vice president at HGCreative. Follow him on Twitter @KevinPWalling.

Why 2026 should terrify Republicans after Tennessee special election